MEMBERS:
SEN. JON C. BUMSTEAD, MAJORITY VICE CHAIR
SEN. RICK OUTMAN
SEN. WAYNE A. SCHMIDT
SEN. SEAN MCCANN, MINORITY VICE CHAIR
THE SENATE
COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
SENATOR ED MCBROOM
CHAIR
7200 BINSFELD OFFICE BUILDING
P.O. BOX 30036
LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909-7536
PHONE: (517) 373-7840
FAX: (517) 373-3932
COMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES
March 3, 2021
A meeting of the Senate Committee on Natural Resources was scheduled for Wednesday, March 3, 2021, at 8:30
a.m., in Room 403 of the Capitol Building.
__________________________________________________________________________________________
The agenda summary is as follow:
1. Reported SB 178 (Sen. McBroom) with recommendation and immediate effect.
2. Testimony regarding SR 20 (Sen. McBroom).
__________________________________________________________________________________________
The Chair called the meeting to order at 8:37 a.m. He instructed the Clerk to call the roll. At that time, the
following members were present: Chair McBroom, Sen.(s) Bumstead, Outman, Schmidt, and McCann, a
quorum was present.
The Chair invited the committee to recite the Pledge of Allegiance.
The Chair entertained a motion by Sen. Schmidt to adopt the meeting minutes from February 24, 2021. Without
objection, the minutes were adopted.
The Chair summarized SB 178 for the committee.
The Chair invited the following individuals to present testimony via zoom regarding SB 178:
Spencer Nevins, Michigan Beer and Wine Wholesalers Association – Support.
Al Chittaro, Faygo Beverages – Support.
Paul Connors, Michigan Department of Treasury – Neutral.
The Chair read the cards of those individuals not wishing to present testimony regarding SB 178:
Juan Escareno, Midwest Independent Retailers Association – Support.
Bill Wolfson, Great Lakes Water Authority – Neutral.
The Chair entertained a motion by Sen. Bumstead to report SB 178 to the floor with recommendation that it
pass. The vote was as follows:
Yeas: Chair McBroom, Sen.(s) Bumstead, Outman, and McCann
Nays: None
The motion prevailed and the bill was reported.
The Chair moved to recommend immediate effect for SB 178. Without objection, immediate effect was
recommended.
The Chair summarized SR 20 for the committee. Member questions followed.
The Chair invited the following individuals to present testimony via zoom regarding SR 20:
Amy Trotter, Michigan United Conservation Clubs – Support. Member questions followed.
Beatrice Friedlander, Attorneys for Animals and a coalition of multiple conservation,
animal/wildlife advocacy and protection groups – Oppose. Member questions followed.
Julie Baker, Songbird Protection Coalition – Oppose. Member questions followed.
Liz Throckmorton, Michigan Audubon – Oppose. Member questions followed.
Mark Jones, Self – Oppose. Member questions followed.
The following individuals submitted a testimony card regarding SR 20:
Molly Tamulevich, Humane Society of the United States – Oppose.
Shelly Stahl, Match-e-be-nash-she-wish Band of Pottawatomi – Oppose.
Andrew Vermeesch, Michigan Farm Bureau – Support.
The following individuals submitted written testimony regarding SR 20:
John Krohn, Lansing, MI – Support
Jason Davis – Support
M. Waltz, Waterford – Oppose
Jim Okraszewski, Watermeet – Oppose
Anne Sturtevant, Midland – Oppose
Patsy Mortimer, Hale – Oppose
Kristen Garlock, Saline – Oppose
warblrwatchr@aol.com – Oppose
Kenneth Glynn, Ypsilanti – Oppose
Carolyn Reich, Macomb County – Oppose
Roger Hill – Oppose
Berta Meserve, Lake Ann – Oppose
Susan Creager, Lawton – Oppose
Gina and Jim Lago – Oppose
Mike Chamberlin – Oppose
Margaret Schmidt – Oppose
Ewa Golebiowska, Huntington Woods – Oppose
Kathy Cole – Oppose
Melanie Hilliard and Jason Moritz, Leoni Township – Oppose
Dennis Turay, Dowagiac – Oppose
Maureen O’Halloran, Howell – Oppose
Ann Miller, Benton Harbor – Oppose
Connie Spotts – Oppose
Kirby Ancona, Crozet, VA – Oppose
Cynthia Sabin, East Lansing – Oppose
Janet Scheib, Clarkston – Oppose
Margery Guest – Oppose
Donna Keller, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Deb Popp – Oppose
Alison Heins, Traverse City – Oppose
Wanda Diamond, Maple City – Oppose
Kathleen Mikusa, Fenton – Oppose
Penny Engstrom – Oppose
Nanci Einstein – Oppose
Steve Henley – Oppose
Elgene Doinidis – Oppose
Debra Huff, Laingsburg – Oppose
Judith and Curtis Brock, Charlevoix – Oppose
ktavery@charter.net – Oppose
Paula Reese, Ortonville – Oppose
Robert Harvie, Milford – Oppose
Patricia Thomas, Lapeer – Oppose
Tara Reynolds, Sterling Heights – Oppose
Vikki Jones, St. Clair – Oppose
Norman Rollins – Oppose
Mark and Barbara Trombly – Oppose
Carole Ralph – Oppose
Kristine Smith, Saginaw – Oppose
Darlene Anderson – Oppose
Michael and Mindy Guzzardo, Brighton – Oppose
Alana Centers, Hastings – Oppose
Traci Wilson, Brooklyn – Oppose
Sharon Freels, Traverse City – Oppose
Paulette Attie, Brimley – Oppose
Mark Jackson, Kalamazoo – Oppose Anita Alden – Oppose
Webb Keane, Ann Arbor – Oppose
Christine Gagne, Howell – Oppose
Robin Lavender – Oppose
Pat Andring, Pinckney – Oppose
Gwen Shavalier, Hamilton – Oppose
Barbara Post, Grand Haven – Oppose
Joan Lutovsky – Oppose
Doreen Zakem – Oppose
Ron Shavalier, Hamilton – Oppose
Jessica Hickey, Henderson – Oppose
Paul Gorley – Oppose
Dan – Oppose
Howard Vogel, Traverse City – Oppose
Katherine McLean – Oppose
Susan Kendall, Lansing – Oppose
Cori Russell – Oppose
Patricia Majors, Petersburg – Oppose
Allisyn Miller – Oppose
Mich Pursley – Oppose
Shannon Ostby, Belleville – Oppose
Leslie Brown – Oppose
Mary Spradling, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Charlie Weaver, Kalkaska – Oppose
Lori Craig, Grand Haven – Oppose
Katherine Batka, East Jordan – Oppose
Joseph Brooks, Grand Traverse County – Oppose
Cindy Stark – Oppose
Joan Durrance, Dexter – Oppose
Alicenine0789@yahoo.com – Oppose
Joe McDonnell – Oppose
Patricia Grupp – Oppose
Patricia Dawes, New Hudson – Oppose
Phil Glomski, Oscoda – Oppose
Cairn – Oppose
John Kimble – Oppose
Robert Morman, Ludington – Oppose
Bonnie LaVoy – Oppose
Stephen Roush – Oppose
Sharon Petzke – Oppose
Dianna and Tim Morand – Oppose
Natasha Koss, Marquette – Oppose
Pamela Sisson, East Lansing – Oppose
Allen and Judy Marr, Williamston – Oppose
Joe Fitzpatrick, Marshall – Oppose
Kathryn West-Brandt – Oppose
Carol Shuckra, East Bay Township – Oppose
Linda and Tom Robertson, Grand Ledge – Oppose
Marilynn Gorman – Oppose
Robert Courson, Traverse City – Oppose
Adara Pasos – Oppose
Deborah Windsand, Haslett – Oppose
Kay and Theron Guild – Oppose
Jan Green, Grand Ledge – Oppose
R. Alexander, Douglas – Oppose
Kathryn McCurdy – Oppose
Stacy Mates, Washtenaw County – Oppose
Nancy Whitelaw, Chelsea – Oppose
Tracey Smith, South Lyon – Oppose
Michelle Areeda, Birmingham – Oppose
Ronna Fisher, Ferndale – Oppose
Linda Leonard – Oppose
Tracey Shafroth, Douglas – Oppose
Gail Schnurstein, Saginaw – Oppose
Tracey Marchyok, Ann Arbor – Oppose
Michelle Kehrle-Sulser, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Karen Owen, East Lansing – Oppose
Lynn McAndrews, Maple City – Oppose
Denise Lassaline – Oppose
Karla Brandao Lange – Oppose
Patricia Elliott, Oscoda – Oppose
Camp4bucks@charter.net – Oppose
Linda Irvin – Oppose
Audrey Hermanson – Oppose
Sonja Colcun, Jerome – Oppose
Kathleen Fedewa – Oppose
Loree Zelenock – Oppose
Darlene Doorlag – Oppose
Alexander Silvestri – Oppose
Carol Long, Portage – Oppose
Peggy Collins, Southfield – Oppose
Bob Barnhart, Okemos – Oppose
Annie Temple – Oppose
Ronnie Fisher – Oppose
Carole Caplan-Sosin – Oppose
Timothy Muffitt, Ann Arbor – Oppose
Arika Lycan – Oppose
Lynette Schreur – Oppose
Janet Clevely – Oppose
Jim Brewer – Oppose
Ruthann Zattlin – Oppose
Erica Clites, Madison Heights – Oppose
Elise Muffitt – Oppose
Debra Huff, Laingsburg – Oppose
Bobbi Spiegler – Oppose
Reuben Flatt, Oxford – Oppose
Terie Vickery – Oppose
Colleen Hyslop, East Lansing – Oppose
Kris – Oppose
Ernie Ayers, Sand Creek – Oppose
Barbara Anderson, East Lansing – Oppose
Sandy McCarrick – Oppose
Jeanine Flannery, Grosse Pointe Woods – Oppose
Amy Campbell – Oppose
Steven Goebel – Oppose
Tom Molter, Three Rivers – Oppose
Karen Keese – Oppose
Debra Glen, Pinckney – Oppose
Sandra Welker, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Cindy August, Baroda – Oppose
Sybil Jarrard, Benzie County – Oppose
Bill Ravlin – Oppose
John and Donna Haack – Oppose
Judy Malmquist – Oppose
Paula Morgan – Oppose
Ben Higdon, Ypsilanti – Oppose
Jennifer Barnett – Oppose
Liz Throckmorton, Okemos – Oppose
Kathlyn Peterson, Okemos – Oppose
Holly Hetfield, Stevensville – Oppose
Maria Dabrowski – Oppose
Sally Notarius – Oppose
Chris Irvine – Oppose
Tina Gloss-Finnell – Oppose
Rose Martell, Calumet – Oppose
Susan Ravlin, Okemos – Oppose
David Notarius, Farmington Hills – Oppose
Kathy Doig, Mason – Oppose
Linda Covey, Williamston – Oppose
Pary Reza – Oppose
Anne Lacy, Baraboo, WI – Oppose
Patricia Johnson, Free Soil – Oppose
Holly Chiddister – Oppose
Mark Muhich, Jackson – Oppose
LeRoy Kramer – Oppose
Joe Moloney – Oppose
Chad Machinski, Woody Plants & Trails Technician – Oppose
Stacy Hofmeister, Grand Ledge – Oppose
Ken DesJardins, Grosse Ile – Oppose
Barbara Toshalis – Oppose
Gordon Striegel, Au Train – Oppose
dakrupa@aol.com – Oppose
Diane Cheklich, Detroit – Oppose
Susan Dubovsky, East Tawas – Oppose
Katharine Frohardt-Lane, Royal Oak – Oppose
Patricia Nelson, Bloomingdale – Oppose
Karen O'Connor, Dexter – Oppose
Larry Wagle – Oppose
Jane Rupchock, Niles – Oppose
Steven Christian Upton – Oppose
Sudhir Reddy – Oppose
Sarah Campbell, Grand Traverse County – Oppose
Carl & Judi Manning, Holland – Oppose
Marjo Jordan, Grand Rapids – Oppose
Rick Forrest, Lake Orion – Oppose
Doris Applebaum, Oak Park – Oppose
Carl & Judi Manning, Holland – Oppose
Joe Ringenberg – Oppose
Camilla Davis, DeWitt – Oppose
James & Janet Senneker, Perty – Oppose
Sabrina Braunlich – Oppose
Bernice Gray – Oppose
Colleen – Oppose
Barbara Broadley – Oppose
Dayna M. – Oppose
Mary Ann Hagemeyer, Fountain – Oppose
Sarah Hoger – Oppose
William Buckingham, Jackson – Oppose
Barbara Saxena, Lansing – Oppose
Lauraduby23@gmail.com – Oppose
Yogesh Saxena, Lansing – Oppose
Michelle Petrak – Oppose
Laurie Mastrogianis – Oppose
Nancy Esser, Harbor Springs – Oppose
Cat Jackson, Spring Lake – Oppose
Patricia Sparks – Oppose
Sue Cross, Grand Rapids – Oppose
David & Priscilla Foran, Williamston – Oppose
Kimberly Snyder – Oppose
Jacqueline Ryan, Manistee – Oppose
Erin Harrelson, Grand Traverse County – Oppose
Kevin Cavanagh & Denise Skalsky, E. Lansing – Oppose
Suzi Straffon – Oppose
Mary Bromley, Farmington Hills – Oppose
Michael Augustine, Mayville – Oppose
Ann Holmes & Brenda Wickett, Dexter Township – Oppose
William Gittlen & Sarah Campbell – Oppose
Heather Peyton, Traverse City – Oppose
Shauna Tindall, Ann Arbor – Oppose
Al Wienhold, Ann Arbor – Oppose
Diane Hanks, Detroit – Oppose
Jean Gramlich, Fenton – Oppose
Charles Kotz, Okemos – Oppose
Tom & Kathy Carnegie – Oppose
Ann Kennedy, Grand Traverse County – Oppose
Michael Knox, Bingham Farms – Oppose
Nancy Van Alstine, Ann Arbor – Oppose
Adela Pinch – Oppose
Karen Schwalm – Oppose
Margay Britton – Oppose
Lauren Taylor, Cadillac – Oppose
James Bradley, Grand Rapids – Oppose
Dorothy Zahor, Ypsilanti – Oppose
Phil Davis – Oppose
Beth Hoger – Oppose
Georgia Halloran, Warren – Oppose
Mary MacDonwell, Grand Traverse County – Oppose
Kent Moncur – Oppose
Michael & Heather Allen – Oppose
Janet Ricco, Delton – Oppose
James Harding, Okemos – Oppose
John & Suzanne Kowalski – Oppose
Kerry O'Hare – Oppose
Glenn Dunn, Lansing – Oppose
Ken Sapkowski, Allendale – Oppose
Sue Hoger – Oppose
Carol Giancola, E. Lansing – Oppose
Michelle Ervin, Ortonville – Oppose
Don & Kathy Ehrenberger, Traverse City – Oppose
Debbie Wolf, Lansing – Oppose
John Prokes, Honor – Oppose
Lori Toivola, Indian River – Oppose
Fred Allen, Pentwater – Oppose
Ann Merritt, Grand Traverse County – Oppose
Mary Kinney, Delton – Oppose
David Moore, Saugatuck – Oppose
Charlotte Stewart – Oppose
Andrea Zinkus – Oppose
Lucy Maillette, Okemos – Oppose
Carmelita Lovett, Horton – Oppose
Arthur & Inge Kyler, Eaton Rapids – Oppose
George & Cyndy Mikulyuk, Pentwater – Oppose
Cam Mannino & Reg Brown, Oakland – Oppose
Theresa Tithof – Oppose
Elise Brooks, Grand Traverse County – Oppose
Russ Tithof – Oppose
Suzanne Baker, Livonia – Oppose
Nancy McIntyre – Oppose
Sandra & Steve Wojtowicz, Wahsington – Oppose
Ellen Moore-Sarjeant – Oppose
Michael Disbrow, Manton – Oppose
Arthur & Judith Frock, Midland – Oppose
LuAnn Crim – Oppose
Linda McCallum – Oppose
Nichole LaVigne – Oppose
Lorine Shack – Oppose
Terry Karjalainen – Oppose
Terri Keppler – Oppose
Nancy Verhaeghe, Washington Township – Oppose
Kayne Ferrioer – Oppose
Joe Flickema – Oppose
Karen Barton – Oppose
William Droll – Oppose
Lynn Babcock, Dexter – Oppose
Michael & Joanne Cromley, Afton – Oppose
Ronald Swenson – Oppose
Pam & George Wright, Farmington – Oppose
Ronald Marinch, Okemos – Oppose
Bonnie Schwartzkopf, Riley – Oppose
Gerard Fields, Flushing – Oppose
Mark Isken – Oppose
Kathleen Swindlehurst – Oppose
Debra Laurie, Autrain – Oppose
Patricia Winebrenner – Oppose
Patricia Power – Oppose
Marion Spencer, Ann Arbor – Oppose
Maribeth Fletcher – Oppose
Tim Katafias – Oppose
Thomas Winebrenner – Oppose
Rob Lyerla, East Leroy – Oppose
Marlene Mackie – Oppose
Edward Pietrzyk – Oppose
Penelope Bach, Pentwater – Oppose
Rick & Tonya, Alden – Oppose
Paula Reese, Ortonville – Oppose
Scott Nottmeier, Warren – Oppose
Marcia Maher, Marshall – Oppose
Mary Droste – Oppose
Jennifer Mann – Oppose
Patricia Tarini, Okemos – Oppose
Anna Rowe Love, Grand Traverse County – Oppose
John Eisenhardt, Dexter – Oppose
Janine Spencer-Glasson, Linden – Oppose
Kathy Nohr – Oppose
Mark Ladenson – Oppose
Joel Kahaner – Oppose
John & Karen Thornton – Oppose
A.M. Burns, Eagle – Oppose
Joy Frawley, E. Lansing – Oppose
Chris Campbell, Traverse City – Oppose
Darlene Friedman, Novi – Oppose
Michael Motta, Holland Charter Township – Oppose
Joyce Root – Oppose
Nancy Warren, Ewen – Oppose
Mary Fisher-Dunham, Three Oaks – Oppose
John Prokes, Honor – Oppose
Mary Glidden, Rochester Hill, MI – Oppose
Alice Van Zoeren, Maple City, MI – Oppose
Sherri Smith, Ann Arbor, MI – Oppose
Leah Monger, Big Rapids, MI – Oppose
John and Adele Bayley – Oppose
John Collins – Oppose
Jackie McClelland, Hastings, MI – Oppose
Julia Moore, Imlay City, MI – Oppose
Wesley Jacobs – Oppose
Constance Olson – Oppose
Deanna Vetrone, Troy, MI – Oppose
Nancy Schanz – Oppose
Susan Fisher, Ann Arbor, MI – Oppose
Jennifer Porter, Perry, MI – Oppose
Amanda Nayback – Oppose
Tom and Lauri Holmes, Kalamazoo MI – Oppose
Ruth Peppers, Manistee MI – Oppose
Scott Gritter – Oppose
Deb Johnson – Oppose
Nadine Cloutier, Brighton, MI – Oppose
Linda Bergles-Daul, Northville, MI – Oppose
Emmy Lou Cholak – Oppose
Barbara Drouillard – Oppose
Kathy Cook-Dowd – Oppose
Tina Trettin – Oppose
L. Zahn – Oppose
Michael Jehle, Ludington, MI – Oppose
Charles Crawford, Empire, MI – Oppose
Stephanie Jackson – Oppose
Douglas and Sally Cook, Benzie MI – Oppose
Paula DeGregorio, Pentwater, MI – Oppose
Tom Papcun Ludington, MI – Oppose
Gary Gielczyk, Honor, MI – Oppose
Maggi Singer – Oppose
Mary Schafer – Oppose
Betsy Davidson – Oppose
Claudia Myers, Ludington, MI – Oppose
Sue Handsy – Oppose
David Bunce, Cadillac, MI – Oppose
Deborah Garrow, Grand Rapids, MI – Oppose
John Lindberg, Battle Creek, MI – Oppose
Melissa Welke – Oppose
Marilyn Conley – Oppose
Jackie Schmitz, Middleville, MI – Oppose
Dave Hall – Oppose
Christine Hall – Oppose
Jeanne Church, Kalamazoo MI – Oppose
Sharon Freels, Traverse City MI – Oppose
Elizabeth Bishop, Ann Arbor MI – Oppose
JoEllen Rudolph, Petoskey, MI – Oppose
Carla Wilson-Neil, Hastings, MI – Oppose
Susan Beecher, Chelsea, MI – Oppose
Ilse Gebhard Audubon Society of Kalamazoo, MI – Oppose
Shirley Fletcher, Livingston County, MI – Oppose
Michael Lombardo, Grand Haven, MI – Oppose
gretstaub@gmail.com – Oppose
H.F. Brainard, Ludington, MI – Oppose
Carol Gagliardi – Oppose
Carmen Muscat – Oppose
Ewa Kedzieraska, Livonia MI – Oppose
David Gordon, Ann Arbor, MI – Oppose
Kathie Hepler – Oppose
Sharon Morman – Oppose
Janet Bigelow – Oppose
Linda M. Lobik – Oppose
Jim Strohmer, Grand Rapids, MI – Oppose
Christine Allen, Beverley Hills, MI – Oppose
June Thaden, Traverse City MI – Oppose
Paula Allred – Oppose
Jane Huggins, Fenton, MI – Oppose
William C. Scharf – Oppose
Philip Micklin, Kalamazoo MI – Oppose
Rayne Bransdorfer-Polasek, PawPaw MI – Oppose
Kim Scherschligt, Dewitt, MI – Oppose
Karen Chadwick, Kalamazoo, MI – Oppose
Candace Gorman, Interlochen, MI – Oppose
William McMullin, Oak Park, MI – Oppose
Bradley Anderson, Brigman, MI – Oppose
Stephen Ross, Rodney, MI – Oppose
George Maker, Beluah, MI – Oppose
Carol Rappold – Oppose
Martha garbermd33@gmail.com – Oppose
Shelley Cowan, Traverse City, MI – Oppose
Janyce Ryan, Portage MI – Oppose
Melanie Woodrich, Troy, MI – Oppose
Deborah Roels, Munith MI – Oppose
Pat Breniser – Oppose
John Dykstra, Hopkins, MI – Oppose
Jackie Jackson – Oppose
Tom and Beth Aitiken – Oppose
Lura L. Shaw – Oppose
Joanne Lower, Portage MI – Oppose
Pamela Moyer – Oppose
DeLora B. Krogel – Oppose
Joe Loloney Sable Dunes Audubon Society – Oppose
Mary Jarrard – Oppose
Ken and Geraldine Grunow, Dearborn, MI – Oppose
Jill Fisher, Hancock, MI – Oppose
Rose Morand, Harbor Beach, MI – Oppose
Brent McCumons, Chelsea, MI – Oppose
David Hofmeister – Oppose
Anne Lacy, Baraboo, WI – Oppose
Stacy Hofmeister, Grand Ledge, MI – Oppose
Jann and Michael Nestell, Williamston, MI – Oppose
Gwendolyn Buschell, Beverley Hills, MI – Oppose
Patricia Miller, Ann Arbor, MI – Oppose
Kendra Flynn, Pentwater, MI – Oppose
Judy Florian, Grosse Pointe Park, MI – Oppose
Peggy Waterman, Chelsea, MI – Oppose
Nancy VerMerris, Fruitport, MI – Oppose
Sophia DiPietro, All Species Kinship – Oppose
Liggie Perkins – Oppose
Vicki Lynas – Oppose
Kathy Monear – Oppose
Kim Bayer, Ann Arbor, MI – Oppose
Patrick Marutiak, Owosso, MI – Oppose
Lyda Stillwell, Kalamazoo, MI – Oppose
David Dister, Hamlin Township – Oppose
Peggy Haverberg, Free Soil, MI – Oppose
Renee Kermeen, Middleville, MI – Oppose
Toni Spears, Dexter, MI – Oppose
Doris Cubberly, Tecumseh, MI – Oppose
David and MaryAnne Marvin, Traverse City, MI – Oppose
Mary E. Marshall, Manistee – Oppose
Kari Dylhoff – Oppose
Mary Ann Tomaszewski, Honor, MI – Oppose
Rodrigo Andrade, Grosse Pointe Woods, MI – Oppose
Nancy Boyce, East Lansing, MI – Oppose
Amy Seiferlein, Warren, MI – Oppose
Stacy Slater – Oppose
Kathleen Anzicek and Mark Leventer, Grass Lake, MI – Oppose
Carolyn Ptaszenski – Oppose
Beverly Brown – Oppose
Sue Jennings, Lake Anne, MI – Oppose
Brenda Earl – Oppose
Mary Armstrong, Frankfort, MI – Oppose
William Weld-Wallis, Grand Rapids – Oppose
Karla Stanley – Oppose
Phillip Reid, Clarkston MI – Oppose
Melissa Lorenz, Montague, MI – Oppose
Ted and Gretchen Iorio, Traverse City, MI – Oppose
Patricia MacIntosh, Traverse City, MI – Oppose
Amy Gamble, Jackson, MI – Oppose
Leeya Correll, Ann Arbor, MI – Oppose
Carolyn Swanson, Williamston, MI – Oppose
Marianne Arbogast – Oppose
Mary Caldwell – Oppose
Sue Ann Hanson, Ludington, MI – Oppose
Rachel Nizinski – Oppose
Karen Tracey, Grand Rapids – Oppose
Suz McLaughlin, Frankfort, MI – Oppose
Brian M. Smith, PawPaw, MI – Oppose
Terri Andrews – Oppose
Terry L. Stiles, Oakland County – Oppose
Nancy Cornett, Roscommon MI – Oppose
Kathleen Bricker, Commerce Twp. – Oppose
Ann Rogers, Traverse City, MI – Oppose
Marlana Bernheisel – Oppose
EileenHeuvelhort@gmail.com – Oppose
Ed Rumsas – Oppose
Kathleen Hempsall Willimson – Oppose
Ilse Gebhard, Kalamazoo, MI – Oppose
Lisa Reich – Oppose
Lisa and Stephen Baker, Saugatuck, MI – Oppose
Carol Towar, Traverse City, MI – Oppose
Nancy A. Smith, Liberty Township, MI – Oppose
Tracey Boulton, Belding, MI – Oppose
Sandra Smith, East Lansing, MI – Oppose
Sharon Dorrity, Sault Ste. Marie, MI – Oppose
Dr. Catherine Rowe-Lonczynski, Washington, MI – Oppose
James Markham, Grand Rapids, MI – Oppose
Richard and Susan Rigterink, Ann Arbor, MI – Oppose
Michael Niebel – Oppose
Ann Hepenstal, Onekama, MI – Oppose
Betty Tabor, Ludington, MI – Oppose
Dr. Foster B. Gibbs – Oppose
Mort Smythe – Oppose
Susan Rauschl – Oppose
Jessie Voigts, Kalamazoo, MI – Oppose
Maria Maki, PawPaw, MI – Oppose
Nicole Mussen, Ypsilanti, MI – Oppose
Peg Gage, Free Soil, MI – Oppose
Phleberta – Oppose
Megan Short, Mason – Oppose
Dorinda VanKempen, E. Lansing – Oppose
Bstaley8@yahoo.com – Oppose
Brock Morman – Oppose
Cynthia Sherman-Jones – Oppose
Ann Fitzpatrick – Oppose
Megan Tinsley, Lansing – Oppose
Donald Verhaeghe – Oppose
Richard Thomas, Plainwell – Oppose
Kathryn Phelan, West Bloomfield – Oppose
Joseph Hell, E. Lansing – Oppose
Melissa West – Oppose
Kim Ray, Brighton – Oppose
Judy & Joe Derek – Oppose
Seth McRobb, Salem – Oppose
Tina Teague – Oppose
Stella Jay, Brighton – Oppose
Chris Clough – Oppose
Dave Posther, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Deborah Betz, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Beth & Mark Kudla, Clarkston – Oppose
Anne Smith, Brownstown – Oppose
Christine Wilkins-Goodearl, Novi – Oppose
Lisa Schaller – Oppose
Barbara Faller – Oppose
Barbara Iris Potter, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Roselynn Kirschke – Oppose
Jean Cavanaugh, Belleville – Oppose
Eileen Wilson – Oppose
Jan Brintnall – Oppose
Laura McQuarter – Oppose
Marian Emery, Clarkston – Oppose
Anna Thomas, Clarkston – Oppose
Jody Gorman, Brighton – Oppose
Lisa Morman – Oppose
Sheila Partington – Oppose
Kris Ann DeAngelo – Oppose
Brenda Keith, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Richard & Brenda Keith, Vicksburg – Oppose
Sheila Blackwell – Oppose
Francie Kodlowski – Oppose
Sarah Goldstein, Ann Arbor – Oppose
Dan Kamerman, Delton – Oppose
Sigrid Grace, Rochester Hills – Oppose
Jessica Shutler, Royal Oak – Oppose
Virginia Lavender, Lake Orion – Oppose
Anne Rogers, Beulah – Oppose
Julie Baker, MI Songbird Protection Coalition – Oppose
Robert Clement, Beverly Hills – Oppose
Kim Rock, Grosse Ile – Oppose
Duane Dunlap & Nancy Hulka, Muskegon – Oppose
William Clarke, Northville – Oppose
William Ecklund, Texas Township – Oppose
Lynn Russell Kermeen, Middleville – Oppose
Abigail Dean, Portage – Oppose
Linda Bruneau – Oppose
Marilyn Childers – Oppose
Amanda Paul, Kalamazoo – Oppose
Mary Handley, Portage – Oppose
Richard Brown – Oppose
Jerid Shutler, Royal Oak – Oppose
Phillip D'Lavender, Lake Orion – Oppose
Richard Wojciechowski, Oxford – Oppose
Jill Rheinheimer – Oppose
Jolene Knapp – Oppose
Barbara Wait Kruegher, Hartland – Oppose
There being no further business before the committee, the Chair entertained a motion by Sen. Schmidt to
adjourn the committee. Without objection, the committee was adjourned at 9:47 a.m.
Date adopted by committee: 03/10/2021