HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
COMMITTEE ON LABOR
REP. JIM HAADSMA
CHAIR
COMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES
Wednesday, March 8, 2023
9:00 AM
Room 308, House Office Building
The House Committee on Labor was called to order by Chair Haadsma.
The Chair requested attendance be called:
Present: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela,
Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Absent: None.
Excused: None.
Representative Churches moved to adopt the meeting minutes from March 2, 2023. There
being no objection, the motion prevailed by unanimous consent.
The Chair laid HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB 4007 before the committee:
HB 4004
(Rep. Weiss)
A bill to amend 1947 PA 336, entitled "An act to
prohibit strikes by certain public employees; to
provide review from disciplinary action with
respect thereto; to provide for the mediation of
grievances and the holding of elections; to declare
and protect the rights and privileges of public
employees; to require certain provisions in
collective bargaining agreements; to prescribe
means of enforcement and penalties for the
violation of the provisions of this act; and to make
appropriations," by amending sections 9, 10, and
15 (MCL 423.209, 423.210, and 423.215), as
amended by 2014 PA 414.
HB 4005
(Rep. Weiss)
A bill to amend 1939 PA 176, entitled "An act to
create a commission relative to labor disputes, and
to prescribe its powers and duties; to provide for
the mediation and arbitration of labor disputes,
and the holding of elections thereon; to regulate
the conduct of parties to labor disputes and to
require the parties to follow certain procedures; to
regulate and limit the right to strike and picket; to
protect the rights and privileges of employees,
including the right to organize and engage in
lawful concerted activities; to protect the rights
and privileges of employers; to make certain acts
unlawful; to make appropriations; and to prescribe
means of enforcement and penalties for violations
of this act," by amending sections 1, 2, 8, 14, 17,
and 22 (MCL 423.1, 423.2, 423.8, 423.14, 423.17,
and 423.22), as amended by 2012 PA 348.
HB 4007
(Rep. Brenda Carter)
A bill to require prevailing wages and fringe
benefits on state projects; to establish the
requirements and responsibilities of contracting
agents and bidders; and to prescribe penalties.
Representative Weiss testified in support of HB 4004and HB 4005. Questions and discussion
followed.
Representative Brenda Carter testified in support of HB 4007. Questions and discussion
followed.
Ryan Sebolt, representing the Michigan American Federation of Labor and Congress of
Industrial Organizations, testified in support of HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB 4007. Questions
and discussion followed.
Jessica Smith, representing the United Food and Commercial Workers 876, testified in
support of HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB 4007. Questions and discussion followed.
Lee Graham, representing the Operating Engineers 324, testified in support of HB 4004, HB
4005 and HB 4007. Questions and discussion followed.
Yousef Rabhi, Jessica Lannon, and Jeremy Lapham, representing the Michigan Nurses
Association, testified in support of HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB 4007. Questions and
discussion followed.
Jon Byrd, representing the Michigan Laborers Union, testified in support of HB 4004, HB
4005 and HB 4007.
Tim Minotas, representing the Sierra Club, testified in support of HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB
4007.
Sean McBrearty, representing Clean Water Action, testified in support of HB 4004, HB 4005
and HB 4007.
Jonas Peterson, representing Southwest Michigan First, testified in opposition to HB 4004
and HB 4005. Questions and discussion followed.
Jimmy Greene, representing the Associated Builders and Contractors of Michigan, testified in
opposition to HB 4007. Questions and discussion followed.
Price Dobernick, representing the Michigan Pipe Trades Association, testified in support of
HB 4007. Questions and discussion followed.
Jeannette Bradshaw, representing the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers State
Conference, testified in support of HB 4007. Questions and discussion followed.
The following person submitted a card in support of HB 4004 and HB 4005, but due to the
time constraints was unable to speak:
Rudolfo Reyes, representing themselves.
The following people submitted a card in opposition to HB 4004 and HB 4005, but due to the
time constraints were unable to speak:
John Kalb, representing the National Right to Work Committee.
Steve Delie, representing the Mackinac Center for Public Policy.
Philip Taylor, representing the Michigan Right to Work Committee.
Dave Worthams, representing the Michigan Manufacturers Association.
The following person submitted a card in opposition to HB 4005, but due to the time
constraints was unable to speak:
Wendy Block, representing the Michigan Chamber of Commerce.
The following person submitted a card in opposition to HB 4007, but due to the time
constraints were unable to speak:
Michael LaFaive, representing the Mackinac Center for Public Policy.
The following people submitted a card in support of HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB 4007, but
due to the time constraints were unable to speak:
Steve Claywell, representing the Michigan Building Trades Council.
Kennedy Parker, representing themselves.
Julie Loeke, representing the United Auto Workers.
Steve Dawes, representing the United Auto Workers Region 1D.
Lance A. Rhines, representing the Office and Professional Employees International
Union Local 459.
Zachary Aaron Northrup, representing Local 2-585.
The following people submitted a card in opposition to HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB 4007, but
due to the time constraints were unable to speak:
Cole Thompson, representing themselves.
Amanda Fisher, representing the National Federation of Independent Business.
The following person submitted a card in support of HB 4004, but did not wish to speak:
Jon DeRoo, representing the Detroit Plumbers Local 98.
The following person submitted a card in support of HB 4005, but did not wish to speak:
Blaine Farr, representing Labor.
The following people submitted a card in support of HB 4004 and HB 4005, but did not wish
to speak:
Merissa Kovach, representing the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan.
Rachel Richards, representing the Michigan League for Public Policy.
DeAndra Davis, representing the Communications Workers of America.
Charles Daniels and Michael Scauhe, representing the Communications Workers of
America District 4.
Diane Payne, representing the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace
Workers Local 698.
Sarah Woolsey, representing themselves.
Bill Flory, representing the Michigan Association for Justice.
Branden Gemzer, representing the Members of UAE.
The following people submitted a card in opposition to HB 4004 and HB 4005, but did not
wish to speak:
Jimmy Greene, representing the Associated Builders and Contractors of Michigan.
Amy Drumm, representing the Michigan Retailers Association.
Ben Tirrell, representing the Michigan Farm Bureau.
James Lilly, representing Spartan Nash.
Caitlyn Stark, representing the Cadillac Area Chamber of Commerce.
John McNamara, representing the Michigan Restaurant and Lodging Association.
Annie Patnaude, representing Americans for Prosperity.
The following people submitted a card in support of HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB 4007, but
did not wish to speak:
Matt Sahr, representing the Michigan Professional Fire Fighters Union.
Carl Castiglione, representing the Plumbers Local Union 98.
Phil Bianco, representing the United Association of Employees.
Holly Simon, representing themselves.
Stephanie Johnson, representing the Utility Workers Union of America.
Benjamin D. Orjada, representing themselves.
Steven Karber and Maria Enriquez, representing the United Auto Workers Local 6000.
Ashley Huff and Monica Artis, representing the Office and Professional Employees
International Union.
John DeRoo, representing the Detroit Plumbers Local 98.
Mike Hayter, Joel Archibald, Geno Alessandroni, Paul Zurek, Dylan Burnette, Jacob
Hilliker, Scott Hamilton, Dave Willert, and Dan Minton, representing the Laborers'
International Union of North America.
Myranda Knapp, Nick Richmond, Dan Spencer, Kathy Clay, and Thomas Woodgate,
representing the United Steel Workers Local 2-585.
Jenell Mansfield, representing the American Federation of Teachers.
Scott Stone, representing the Local 36.
Chad J. Jansen and Aaron Pangborn,, representing the International Brotherhood of
Electrical Workers Local 665.
Trevor Bidelman, representing the Bakery, Confectionery, Tobacco Workers and Grain
Millers International Union.
Ken Kolp, Gregory Remington, and Kellogg Dipzinski, representing the International
Brotherhood of Electrical Workers.
Rod Richards, representing the Retail, Wholesale and Department Store Union Local
530.
Robert Steele, representing the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers 252.
Denise Caldwell, representing the Coalition of Labor Union Women and United Auto
Workers.
Mike Orvosh and Seth Orvosh, representing the United Steel Workers Local 12934.
Mark Willingham and Kimberly DeMott, representing the United Auto Workers.
Joseph Marutiak, Sharon Taylor, Ronda Ackerson, Cynthia Dine, and Lois Davis-
Thomas, representing the Office and Professional Employees International Union Local
459.
Derek Dobies, Courtney Towsley, Freddie Kelly, Regina Jones, Errin Whitaker, Ivy
Chandler, Joseph Bellgowan, Ken Toll, Angela Haynes, Vanessa Lee, Michael Kohler,
and Courtney Alexander, representing the American Federation of Labor and Congress of
Industrial Organizations of Michigan.
Ethan Petzoid, representing the Michigan League of Conservation Voters.
Todd Regis, representing the United Food and Commercial Workers 951.
Representative Donavan McKinney, representing Michigan's 14th House District.
Sean Egan and Todd Cook, representing the Michigan Department of Labor.
Mike Janca, representing the International Union of Elevator Constructors Local 85.
Emily Smith, Henrietta Hadley, and Anne Fairchild, representing the American
Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations of Michigan Workforce
Development Institute.
Josephine Jabara, representing the Michigan Workforce Development Institute.
Arthur Kroll, representing the Steelworkers.
Gwen Jordan, representing themselves.
Gerard McMurran, representing the Steelworkers Retirees.
Julie Rowe, representing themselves.
Janette Christmas, Jerry Young, and Robert Gaynier, representing the United Food and
Commercial Workers 876.
Steven Donovan, representing the United Steel Workers.
Samuel Cardena, representing the Pipefitters Local Union 636.
Jeremy Garza, representing the Michigan Pipe Trades Association.
Scott Huff, Vince Dawe, Casey Baucha, Michael Murray, Steve McCool, and Dan
Fergueroa, representing the Michigan Regional Council of Carpenters.
Johnny Ortiz, representing the United Association Local Union 174.
Nathan Phillips, representing the West Michigan Labor Council.
Mark Palice, representing the Laborers Union.
Isaiah Minor and Spencer Calhoun, representing Labor.
Rose Dietz, Tim Ferguson, Fred Jimenez, and Rhonda Richards, representing the Retail,
Wholesale and Department Store Union.
Alex Zurek, representing Michigan Laborers.org.
Elizabeth Kelly Byrd, representing the Service Employees International Union of
Michigan.
Arlandar Washington, representing the Laborers' International Union of North America
Local 355.
Kenneth James Bickle, representing the Utility Workers Union of America.
Lynda Schnepp, representing the Michigan Laborers District.
Katie Bargund, Robert Joerg, and Paul Husted, representing the Michigan Laborers.
Shandon Claspell, representing the Utility Workers Union of America Local 253.
Connor Wood, representing themselves.
Nick DeFauw, representing the Laborers.
Drake Minton, representing the Laborers.
Steven Rzeppa, representing the American Federation of State, County and Municipal
Employees Council 25.
Eli Isaguirre, representing the Michigan Regional Council of Carpenters and Millwrights.
Ben Lyons, representing the Laborers' International Union of North America Local 499.
Donald Roach, representing the International Association of Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and
Transportation Workers.
Todd Tennis, representing the Amalgamated Transit Union, Michigan Legislative
Conference, and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Michigan State
Conference.
The following people submitted a card in opposition to HB 4004, HB 4005 and HB 4007, but
did not wish to speak:
Beth DeShone, representing the Great Lakes Education Project.
Jase Bolger, representing the West Michigan Policy Forum.
Andy Johnston, representing the Grand Rapids Chamber.
Arthur Havlicek, representing the Southwest Michigan Regional Chamber.
Sarah Anderson, representing the Michigan Freedom Fund.
Stephanie Kreuz, representing Heritage Action for America.
Sandy Baruah, representing the Detroit Regional Chamber.
Brian Calley, representing the Small Business Association of Michigan.
Dawn Crandall, representing the Home Builders Association of Michigan.
The following people submitted a card in support of HB 4007, but did not wish to speak:
Mike Schucer, representing the Communications Workers of America District 4.
Bill Flory, representing the Michigan Association for Justice.
Damian Hill, representing the Associated General Contractors of Michigan.
The following person submitted a card in opposition to HB 4007, but did not wish to speak:
Wendy Block, representing the Michigan Chamber of Commerce.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendment to HB 4004:
1. Amend page 8, following line 11, by inserting:
"Sec. 10a. (1) A bargaining representative shall provide to each public employee in the
bargaining unit that the bargaining representative represents, not later than 90 days
after the effective date of the amendatory act that added this section or at the time the
public employee becomes employed in that unit, the following statement in writing:
"Under the United States Supreme Court decision Janus v AFSCME, Council 31,
___US___; 138 S Ct 2448 (2018), it is a violation of a public employee's first amendment
free speech rights for a public-sector bargaining representative to require the public
employee to pay dues or fees to the bargaining representative unless the public
employee consents."
(2) A public employee may cease paying dues or fees to a bargaining representative at
any time.
(3) A bargaining representative that violates subsection (1) or prohibits a public
employee from exercising the public employee's right under subsection (2) is subject to a
civil fine of not more than $250.00 for each violation.".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4004. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendment to HB 4004:
1. Amend page 3, line 26, after "representative." by inserting "An agreement described in
this subdivision must provide for both of the following:
(i) That if an officer of the exclusive bargaining representative for the unit is convicted
of a felony related to the finances of the exclusive bargaining representative, a public
employee in the unit is not required to pay any dues or fees to the exclusive bargaining
representative.
(ii) That if an officer of the regional or national office of the exclusive bargaining
representative is convicted of a felony related to the finances of the exclusive bargaining
representative, a public employee in the unit is not required to pay to the exclusive
bargaining representative the portion of the public employee's dues or fees that would
otherwise be remitted to the regional or national office.".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4004. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Kunse moved to adopt substitute (H-4) to HB 4004. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendment to HB 4005:
1. Amend page 4, following line 17, by inserting:
"Sec. 10a. (1) A labor organization shall provide to each employee in the bargaining unit
that the labor organization represents, not later than 90 days after the effective date of
the amendatory act that added this section or at the time the employee becomes
employed in that unit, the following statement in writing: "Under the United States
Supreme Court decision Communications Workers of America v Beck, 487 US 735 (1988),
an employee is not required to pay a due or fee to a labor organization that the labor
organization does not use for collective bargaining, contract administration, and
grievance adjustment.".
(2) An employee may cease paying dues or fees described in subsection (1) to a labor
organization at any time. A labor organization shall provide to each employee in the
bargaining unit that the labor organization represents, at the time the employee
becomes employed in the unit and annually, instructions in writing that explain the
labor organization's process for ceasing these payments.
(3) A labor organization that violates subsection (1) or (2) or that prohibits an employee
from exercising the employee's right under subsection (2) is subject to a civil fine of not
more than $250.00 for each violation.".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4005. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Kunse offered the following amendments to HB 4005:
1. Amend page 6, line 11, by striking out "Nothing" and inserting "Except as otherwise
provided in section 14a, nothing".
2. Amend page 6, following line 22, by inserting:
"Sec. 14a. A city, county, township, or village may authorize a right-to-work zone within
its boundaries by a vote of its governing body or by adoption of a measure initiated by
the people. The commission shall not enforce an all-union shop agreement covering
employees in a right-to-work zone if the employer entered into or renewed the
agreement after the date of adoption of the measure creating the right-to-work zone.".
Representative Kunse moved to adopt the amendments to HB 4005. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendment to HB 4005:
1. Amend page 7, following line 26, by inserting:
"Sec. 29a. Notwithstanding section 29, the commission shall issue an order directing an
election in any existing certified appropriate unit every year following the later of the
effective date of the amendatory act that added this section or the date of initial
certification of a bargaining representative. If the existing certified bargaining
representative receives a majority of the votes cast and the majority represents at least
50% of the employees in the unit, the existing certification continues. If the certified
bargaining representative does not receive a majority vote representing 50% of the
employees in the unit, the existing certification terminates. If certification is terminated,
the terms of the existing contract between the employees represented by the bargaining
representative and the employer continue in effect for the remaining contract term
except for any provisions that involve the duties of or obligations to the bargaining
representative, such as union security, dues and fees, and involvement in grievance and
arbitration procedures.".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4005. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendment to HB 4005:
1. Amend page 4, following line 17, by inserting:
"Sec. 8a. Every calendar quarter, each labor organization that represents employees in
this state shall provide a written report to every employee in every unit that the labor
organization represents and post the report on its website. Each report must include all
of the following information for the immediately preceding calendar quarter:
(a) The name, salary, and amount of fringe benefits of each officer of the labor
organization.
(b) The amount of money that the labor organization paid for all of the following,
delineated by each payment:
(i) Political organizations or activities.
(ii) Charities.
(c) An itemized list of all of the labor organization's expenditures not described in
subdivision (b).".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4005. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendments to HB 4005:
1. Amend page 4, line 18, after "Sec. 14." by inserting "(1)".
2. Amend page 6, following line 22, by inserting:
"(2) An agreement between an employer and a labor organization must provide for both
of the following:
(a) That if an officer of the labor organization that represents the employees in the unit
is convicted of a felony related to the finances of the labor organization, an employee in
the unit is not required to pay any dues or fees to the labor organization.
(b) That if an officer of the regional or national office of the labor organization that
represents the employees in the unit is convicted of a felony related to the finances of the
labor organization, an employee in the unit is not required to pay to the labor
organization the portion of the employee's dues or fees that would otherwise be remitted
to the regional or national office.".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendments to HB 4005. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendment to HB 4007:
1. Amend page 2, line 14, after "agent" by inserting:
"if the cost of the project is greater than or equal to the following:
(i) For a project that consists solely of new construction, $250,000.00.
(ii) For a project that does not consist solely of new construction, $75,000.00".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4007. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Kunse offered the following amendment to HB 4007:
1. Amend page 2, line 14, after "agent" by inserting:
"if the cost of the project is equal to or greater than $150,000.00".
Representative Kunse moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4007. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendment to HB 4007:
1. Amend page 4, following line 26, by inserting:
"Sec. 9. The commissioner shall prepare a report that compares contracts for state
projects that were entered into after January 1, 2019 but before December 31, 2021 to
similar contracts for state projects that are entered into after the effective date of this
act but before 3 years after the effective date of this act. The report must include
comparisons of all of the following for each contract:
(a) The total number of construction mechanics employed.
(b) The total amount of wages paid to construction mechanics.
(c) The total cost of materials.
(d) The total number of safety incidents.
(e) The length of time to complete the state project.
(f) Whether the requirements of this act increased costs and, if so, by how much.".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4007. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak offered the following amendment to HB 4007:
1. Amend page 4, following line 26, by inserting:
"Sec. 9. By 30 months after the effective date of this act, the commission shall submit a
report to the legislature about the impact of this act.
Sec. 10. This act does not apply 3 years after the effective date of this act.".
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4007. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Mueller offered the following amendment to HB 4007:
1. Amend page 4, following line 26, by inserting:
"Sec. 9. A contracting agent that is a local unit of government, public school, community
college, or university may exempt itself from the requirements of this act by a majority
vote of its governing body.".
Representative Mueller moved to adopt the amendment to HB 4007. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Mueller moved to adopt substitute (H-1) to HB 4007. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Wozniak moved to adopt substitute (H-2) to HB 4007. The motion did not
prevail 3-7-0:
UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Nays: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Pass: None.
Representative Koleszar moved to report out HB 4004 with recommendation. The motion
prevailed 7-2-1:
FAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Nays: Reps. Wozniak, Kunse.
Pass: Rep. Mueller.
Representative O'Neal moved to report out HB 4005 with recommendation. The motion
prevailed 7-1-2:
FAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Nays: Rep. Kunse.
Pass: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller.
Representative Churches moved to report out HB 4007 with recommendation. The motion
prevailed 7-3-0:
FAVORABLE ROLL CALL
Yeas: Reps. Haadsma, Mentzer, Koleszar, O'Neal, Andrews, Churches, Wegela.
Nays: Reps. Wozniak, Mueller, Kunse.
Pass: None
There being no further business before the committee, Chair Haadsma adjourned the meeting
at 10:37 AM.
Representative Jim Haadsma, Chair
Edward Sleeper
Committee Clerk
esleeper@house.mi.gov