Who is subject to recall and when

Under MCL 168.951, voters of an officer's electoral district may recall an elective officer, except a judicial officer. A recall petition cannot be submitted for review until the officer has performed the duties of the elected office for 6 months during the current term, or during the last 6 months of the term. For an officer with a term of 2 years or less, a recall petition cannot be filed until the officer has performed the duties of the elected office for 6 months during the current term, or during the last 6 months of the term. For an officer with a term of more than 2 years, a recall petition cannot be filed until the officer has performed the duties of the elected office for 1 year during the current term, or during the last 1 year of the term. An exception applies if recall language was submitted and approved under MCL 168.952 on the effective date of the amendatory act that added the exception: the petition may be filed after 6 months of duties and outside the last 6 months of the term, regardless of the term's length. The officer continues to perform the duties of office until the recall election result is certified.

What the petition must contain and where it goes for review

The petition must be printed, use a form prescribed by the secretary of state, and contain a circulator's certificate, which may be printed on the reverse side. Each reason for recall must be stated factually and clearly and based on the officer's conduct during the current term; the reason may be typewritten. For a petition reviewed by the board of state canvassers, a reason based on the officer's conduct in connection with specific legislation must not misrepresent the content of that legislation. Before circulation, a petition for an officer listed in MCL 168.959 must be submitted to the board of state canvassers. Before circulation, a petition for an officer listed in MCL 168.960 must be submitted to the board of county election commissioners in the county where the officer resides.

How the reasons are reviewed

The board of state canvassers or the board of county election commissioners must notify the officer of each reason and the meeting date no later than 3 business days after receiving the petition. The board must meet no less than 10 days and no more than 20 days after submission to determine whether each reason is factual and sufficiently clear for the officer and electors to identify the conduct that is the basis for recall. The board of state canvassers makes its determination by an affirmative vote of 3 serving members. The officer and the petition sponsors may appear at the meeting and present arguments on whether each reason is factual and sufficiently clear. If any reason is not factual or sufficiently clear, the entire petition must be rejected. If the board does not meet as required, the law treats that failure as a determination that each reason is factual and sufficiently clear.

How a determination can be appealed

The officer or the sponsors of the recall petition drive may appeal the board of state canvassers' determination to the court of appeals or the board of county election commissioners' determination to the circuit court in the county. The appeal must be filed no more than 10 days after the board's determination. If the determination is appealed, the petition is not valid for circulation and must not be circulated until the court determines whether each reason is factual and sufficiently clear or until 40 days after the appeal, whichever is sooner. A petition is not valid for circulation if the applicable court determines at any time that each reason on it is not factual and of sufficient clarity. The petition is valid for 180 days after the later of the board's determination or, if appealed, the earlier of the court's determination or 40 days after the appeal, subject to the rule on a court determination that the reasons are not factual and sufficiently clear. A petition filed after that 180-day period is invalid and the filing official must not accept it, but a person may resubmit it for a determination of clarity and factualness.

Signatures and filing

The petition must have signatures from registered and qualified electors equal to at least 25% of the votes cast for governor candidates at the last preceding general election in the officer's electoral district. Upon written demand, the county clerk must certify the minimum number of signatures required in the governmental unit within 5 days. A petition to recall a United States senator, member of congress, state senator, state representative, elective state officer other than the secretary of state, or county official other than a county commissioner is filed with the secretary of state. A petition to recall the secretary of state is filed with the governor. A petition to recall an elective county commissioner, township, city, village, or school official, or elective metropolitan district officer is filed with the county clerk of the county where the largest portion of registered voters in the electoral district reside. A petition to recall an elective district library board member is filed with the clerk of the largest county, as defined in the district library establishment act. The filing official gives a receipt showing the filing date, the number of petition sheets, and the number of signatures claimed by the filer; the filing is then complete and additional sheets for it cannot be accepted.

How the filing official checks the petition

The filing official must examine the petition within 7 days after filing to determine whether it is in proper form and count its signatures. The filing official must not count signatures on a sheet if the circulator's certificate was not executed in compliance with the act, the heading is improperly completed, or the reasons differ from those determined factual and sufficiently clear by the applicable board or court. The filing official also must not count signatures obtained before the applicable determination date specified in MCL 168.961 or more than 60 days before filing. If the form is improper or the signature count is below the required minimum, the filing official proceeds under the insufficiency provision. If the count exceeds the required minimum, the filing official must verify signers' registration and may check signature genuineness, or must forward each sheet to the city or township clerk named in its heading. A petition for recall of a village official goes from the county clerk to the village clerk, who performs the city or township clerk's duties under MCL 168.961. The city or township clerk must verify registration, may check genuineness, and must attach a certificate within 15 days after receipt indicating the number of signers on each sheet who are registered electors in the city or township and the governmental unit where recall is sought. The qualified voter file is used to verify registration; it creates a rebuttable presumption that a signature is invalid if it shows the signer was not registered to vote, or was not registered in the city or township designated on the petition, on the signing date.

How the officer can challenge signatures

The filing official must notify the officer in writing of the filing no later than the following business day. The officer may challenge a circulator's or signer's registration or the validity and genuineness of a signature by delivering a written challenge specifying the signature to the filing official within 30 days after filing. The officer has at least 8 days after the clerk examines the signatures to check them against the original registration records. The filing official must verify a challenged signature, subject to the rules for using the qualified voter file. For a challenged signature's genuineness, the qualified voter file must be used to compare the signature with the digitized signature; if the file has no digitized signature for the elector, the filing official compares it with the signature on the master card. The qualified voter file may be used to verify a challenged signer's registration, with a rebuttable presumption of invalidity if the file shows the signer was not registered to vote or was not registered in the designated city or township on the signing date.

The sufficiency decision and election

The filing official must make an official declaration of the petition's sufficiency or insufficiency within 35 days after filing. If the petition is insufficient, the filing official must notify the sponsoring person or organization, but notification is not required unless the sponsor filed a written notice of sponsorship and mailing address with the filing official. For a sufficient petition filed under MCL 168.960, the county clerk must call the recall election immediately upon determining sufficiency and no later than 35 days after filing. That recall election must be at least 95 days after filing and on the next May or November regular election date, whichever comes first. For a petition filed under MCL 168.959, the filing official calls a recall primary election on the next regular election date that is at least 95 days after filing, except for a petition to recall the governor. For a petition to recall the governor, the filing official calls a special recall election at least 95 days after filing and on the next May or August regular election date, whichever comes first.