{
  "claim_id": "committee-vote-source-conflicts",
  "claim_type": "validation_result",
  "limitation": "These controlled states have different meanings and must not be summed into a single disagreement rate. A source-total conflict or source-member-choice conflict preserves contradictory vote evidence. A source-kind mismatch preserves a document classification discrepancy. A source placeholder prevents an unresolved participation label from becoming a person.",
  "manifest_url": "/downloads/releases/2026-07-28.3/manifest.json",
  "paper_status": "candidate_finding_not_final_manuscript",
  "release_id": "2026-07-28.3",
  "reproduction": {
    "sqlite_query": "SELECT validation_state, count(*) AS records FROM committee_vote WHERE validation_state IN ('source_total_conflict', 'source_member_choice_conflict') GROUP BY validation_state ORDER BY validation_state;",
    "ui_url": "/research/#validation-flags"
  },
  "review_state": "release_backed_descriptive",
  "section": "Source disagreement",
  "source_tables": [
    {
      "artifacts": [
        {
          "format": "csv.gz",
          "path": "tables/committee_vote/committee_vote.csv.gz",
          "rows": 20038,
          "sha256": "1c3992d57c6b23865653716dab87cd29d6920b83db5d4dc0e327fd83baa35a59"
        },
        {
          "format": "jsonl.gz",
          "path": "tables/committee_vote/committee_vote.jsonl.gz",
          "rows": 20038,
          "sha256": "4b1cbbea739708b8ca37d11f429323d95a8c508210d3970e2d73d60b3f2176bb"
        },
        {
          "format": "parquet",
          "path": "tables/committee_vote/committee_vote.parquet",
          "rows": 20038,
          "sha256": "749746622b4366aad8d78f5ad7b77a4bf42d95b905bc397e9fd648043ceb11e0"
        }
      ],
      "table": "committee_vote"
    }
  ],
  "statement": "19 of 20,038 committee-vote records retain an explicit source-total or source-member-choice conflict state.",
  "title": "Committee votes retaining explicit source conflicts",
  "value": {
    "denominator": 20038,
    "numerator": 19,
    "source_member_choice_conflict": 1,
    "source_total_conflict": 18
  },
  "window": {
    "scope": "all committee_vote rows in the public release"
  }
}