Script-free record · Release 2026-07-28.3

Committee vote · not_prevailed · 12–17–0

Core facts and links below come from the same immutable public release as the enhanced record page.

committee vote

Recorded committee decision

to adopt the amendments for HB 4233, as substitute (H-1).

Meeting date: Not recorded
Result: not prevailed
Yeas: 12
Nays: 17
Validation: consistent
Related meeting: meeting-2578

A committee motion is a proceeding-level decision. A named choice supports that individual vote only and does not establish continuous attendance.

Inspect all published fields

Canonical name: John Cherry
Committee vote id: committee-vote-264371
Evidence text: Representative Cherry moved to adopt the amendments for HB 4233, as substitute (H-1). The motion did not prevail by a vote of 12-17-0. UNFAVORABLE ROLL CALL: Yeas: Reps. Hoadley, Love, Pagan, Hammoud, Peterson, Sabo, Anthony, Brixie, Cherry, Hood, Kennedy, and Tate. Nays: Reps. Hernandez, Miller, Inman, Albert, Allor, Brann, VanSingel, Whiteford, Yaroch, Bollin, Glenn, Green, Huizenga, Lightner, Maddock, Slagh, and VanWoerkom. Pass: None. Representative Brixie offered the following amendment for HB 4233, as substitute (H-1): 1. Amend page 1, line 6, by striking out the balance of the page through "0" on line 21 of page 16 and inserting: "DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY Full-time equated unclassified positions ........ 6.0 Full-time equated classified positions ............................................................ 1,274.0 GROSS APPROPRIATION ........................................................................... $ 472,816,800 Interdepartmental grant revenues: Total interdepartmental grants and intradepartmental transfers .................... 3,176,600 ADJUSTED GROSS APPROPRIATION ..................................................... $ 469,640,200 Federal revenues: Total federal revenues ..................................................................................... 160,895,300 Special revenue funds: Total local revenues .......................................................................................... 0 Total private revenues ....................................................................................... 1,061,800 Total other state restricted revenues .................................................................. 264,446,600 State general fund/general purpose ................................................................... $ 43,236,500 FUND SOURCE SUMMARY Full-time equated unclassified positions ........ 6.0 Full-time equated classified positions ................................................................ 1,274.0 GROSS APPROPRIATION .............................................................................. $ 472,816,800 Interdepartmental grant revenues: IDG from department of state police ................................................................ 1,793,600 IDG from state transportation department ........................................................ 1,383,000 Total interdepartmental grants and intradepartmental transfers ....................... 3,176,600 ADJUSTED GROSS APPROPRIATION ........................................................ $ 469,640,200 Federal revenues: Federal funds...................................................................................................... 160,895,300 Total federal revenues ....................................................................................... 160,895,300 Special revenue funds: Private funds...................................................................................................... 1,061,800 Total private revenues ...................................................................................... 1,061,800 Air emissions fees ............................................................................................ 12,613,200 Aquatic nuisance control fund ......................................................................... 948,400 Campground fund ............................................................................................ 328,600 Clean Michigan initiative - clean water fund ................................................... 2,617,100 Clean Michigan initiative - nonpoint source .................................................... 2,000,000 Cleanup and redevelopment fund ................................................................ 20,253,900 Coal ash care fund ........................................................................................ 260,000 Community pollution prevention fund ......................................................... 250,000 Drinking water declaration of emergency reserve fund ……….................... 100 Electronic waste recycling fund .................................................................... 339,700 Environmental education fund ...................................................................... 176,500 Environmental pollution prevention fund ..................................................... 6,900,800 Environmental protection fund ..................................................................... 2,521,400 Environmental response fund ........................................................................ 5,012,200 Fees and collections ....................................................................................... 395,500 Financial instruments ..................................................................................... 9,555,400 Groundwater discharge permit fees ................................................................ 1,793,900 Infrastructure construction fund ..................................................................... 52,200 Laboratory services fees ................................................................................. 4,361,800 Land and water permit fees ............................................................................ 3,357,400 Landfill maintenance trust fund ..................................................................... 31,000 Medical waste emergency response fund ....................................................... 344,200 Metallic mining surveillance fee revenue ....................................................... 101,100 Mineral well regulatory fee revenue ................................................................ 223,200 Native copper mine fund .................................................................................. 50,000 Nonferrous metallic mineral surveillance ........................................................ 370,200 NPDES fees ...................................................................................................... 4,689,700 Oil and gas regulatory fund .............................................................................. 7,331,200 Orphan well fund .............................................................................................. 4,329,800 Public swimming pool fund .............................................................................. 665,500 Public utility assessments .................................................................................. 420,000 Public water supply fees .................................................................................... 5,057,900 Refined petroleum fund ...................................................................................... 42,407,400 Renew Michigan fund ......................................................................................... 69,000,000 Revitalization revolving loan fund ...................................................................... 103,100 Revolving loan revenue bonds ............................................................................ 15,000,000 Sand extraction fee revenue ................................................................................. 93,000 Scrap tire regulatory fund .................................................................................... 5,127,000 Septage waste program fund ............................................................................... 530,600 Settlement funds .................................................................................................. 427,000 Sewage sludge land application fee ..................................................................... 1,020,000 Small business pollution prevention revolving loan fund ................................... 167,400 Soil erosion and sedimentation control training fund ………………………….. 175,300 Solid waste management fund - staff account ...................................................... 5,304,600 Stormwater permit fees ......................................................................................... 2,527,000 Strategic water quality initiatives fund ................................................................. 1,220,500 Underground storage tank cleanup fund ................................................................ 20,044,300 Wastewater operator training fees ......................................................................... 608,600 Water analysis fees ................................................................................................ 2,275,200 Water pollution control revolving fund ................................................................. 668,900 Water quality protection fund ................................................................................ 100,000 Water use reporting fees ....................................................................................... 294,800 Total other state restricted revenues ..................................................................... 264,446,600 State general fund/general purpose ...................................................................... $ 43,236,500 Sec. 102. DEPARTMENTAL ADMINISTRATION AND SUPPORT Full-time equated unclassified positions ........ 6.0 Full-time equated classified positions ......... 83.0 Unclassified salaries--6.0 FTE positions ............................................................ $ 824,100 Accounting service center ................................................................................... 1,438,000 Administrative hearings ...................................................................................... 396,000 Central support services--39.0 FTE positions ..................................................... 5,239,500 Communications and community outreach--31.0 FTE positions ....................... 4,659,000 Environmental support projects ......................................................................... 5,000,000 Executive direction--13.0 FTE positions ........................................................... 2,133,600 Facilities management ........................................................................................ 1,000,000 Property management .......................................................................................... 7,630,200 GROSS APPROPRIATION ............................................................................... $ 28,320,400 Appropriated from: Interdepartmental grant revenues: IDG from department of state police .................................................................. 76,500 Federal revenues: Federal funds....................................................................................................... 29,800 Special revenue funds: Private funds........................................................................................................ 364,100 Air emissions fees .............................................................................................. 1,534,000 Campground fund ............................................................................................... 15,800 Cleanup and redevelopment fund ....................................................................... 1,611,300 Electronic waste recycling fund .......................................................................... 15,300 Environmental education fund ............................................................................ 176,500 Environmental pollution prevention fund ........................................................... 1,759,700 Environmental protection fund ........................................................................... 327,000 Environmental response fund ............................................................................. 531,600 Fees and collections ............................................................................................ 151,500 Financial instruments ........................................................................................... 7,369,100 Groundwater discharge permit fees ..................................................................... 217,700 Laboratory services fees ...................................................................................... 160,700 Land and water permit fees ................................................................................. 646,800 Medical waste emergency response fund ............................................................ 18,200 Metallic mining surveillance fee revenue ........................................................... 5,200 Mineral well regulatory fee revenue ................................................................... 9,100 Nonferrous metallic mineral surveillance ........................................................... 800 NPDES fees ......................................................................................................... 278,400 Oil and gas regulatory fund .........................................................................……. 948,000 Orphan well fund .................................................................................................... 53,600 Public swimming pool fund .................................................................................... 27,900 Public utility assessments ........................................................................................ 21,400 Public water supply fees .......................................................................................... 291,400 Refined petroleum fund ............................................................................. 2,652,600 Sand extraction fee revenue ....................................................................... 4,300 Scrap tire regulatory fund ........................................................................... 175,600 Septage waste program fund ....................................................................... 20,500 Settlement funds .......................................................................................... 427,000 Sewage sludge land application fee ............................................................. 125,800 Small business pollution prevention revolving loan fund ............................ 19,700 Soil erosion and sedimentation control training fund …………………….. 19,100 Solid waste management fund - staff account ............................................... 371,400 Stormwater permit fees .................................................................................. 266,400 Wastewater operator training fees .................................................................. 35,000 Water analysis fees .......................................................................................... 148,400 Water use reporting fees .................................................................................. 25,000 State general fund/general purpose .................................................................. $ 7,388,200 Sec. 103. WATER RESOURCES DIVISION Full-time equated classified positions ................... 312.0 Aquatic nuisance control program--6.0 FTE positions ………………………. $ 948,400 Expedited water/wastewater permits--1.0 FTE positions……………………. 52,200 Federal - Great Lakes remedial action plan grants ........................................... 583,800 Federal - nonpoint source water pollution grants ............................................. 4,083,300 Fish contaminant monitoring ............................................................................ 316,100 Great Lakes restoration initiative ...................................................................... 6,252,100 Groundwater discharge permit program--22.0 FTE positions .......................... 2,979,900 Land and water interface permit programs--82.0 FTE positions ...................... 12,037,700 Nonpoint source pollution prevention and control project program .................. 2,000,000 NPDES nonstormwater program--83.0 FTE positions ....................................... 13,467,800 Program direction and project assistance--27.0 FTE positions ......................... 3,164,500 Surface water--86.0 FTE positions .................................................................... 15,851,900 Technology advancements for water monitoring .............................................. 500,000 Water quality protection grants ......................................................................... 100,000 Water withdrawal assessment program--5.0 FTE positions………………….. 829,200 Wetlands program ............................................................................................. 800,000 GROSS APPROPRIATION ............................................................................. $ 63,966,900 Appropriated from: Interdepartmental grant revenues: IDG from state transportation department ...................................................... 1,296,900 Federal revenues: Federal funds............................................................................................. 26,967,200 Special revenue funds: Aquatic nuisance control fund .................................................................. 948,400 Clean Michigan initiative fund - clean water fund ................................... 2,617,100 Clean Michigan initiative fund - nonpoint source .................................... 2,000,000 Environmental response fund ................................................................... 1,404,800 Groundwater discharge permit fees .......................................................... 1,479,900 Infrastructure construction fund ............................................................... 52,200 Land and water permit fees ....................................................................... 2,359,400 NPDES fees ............................................................................................... 4,234,300 Refined petroleum fund ............................................................................. 445,900 Sewage sludge land application fee ........................................................... 859,600 Soil erosion and sedimentation control training fund …………………… 143,200 Stormwater permit fees .............................................................................. 2,171,400 Wastewater operator training fees .............................................................. 293,200 Water pollution control revolving fund ...................................................... 146,800 Water quality protection fund ..................................................................... 100,000 Water use reporting fees .............................................................................. 253,400 State general fund/general purpose ............................................................. $ 16,193,200 Sec. 104. LAW ENFORCEMENT Full-time equated classified positions ......... 15.0 Environmental investigations--15.0 FTE positions .................................... $ 3,035,700 GROSS APPROPRIATION ....................................................................... $ 3,035,700 Appropriated from: Federal revenues: Federal funds................................................................................................ 575,800 Special revenue funds: Air emissions fees ........................................................................................ 58,000 Campground fund ........................................................................................ 2,100 Cleanup and redevelopment fund ................................................................ 192,500 Electronic waste recycling fund .................................................................. 1,600 Environmental pollution prevention fund ................................................... 265,400 Environmental response fund ..................................................................... 41,900 Fees and collections .................................................................................... 4,100 Financial instruments .................................................................................. 532,800 Groundwater discharge permit fees ............................................................. 19,600 Laboratory services fees .............................................................................. 17,300 Land and water permit fees .......................................................................... 79,900 Medical waste emergency response fund ..................................................... 2,400 Metallic mining surveillance fee revenue ..................................................... 700 Mineral well regulatory fee revenue ............................................................. 1,200 NPDES fees ................................................................................................... 33,100 Oil and gas regulatory fund ........................................................................... 89,300 Orphan well fund ........................................................................................... 7,100 Public swimming pool fund ........................................................................... 3,700 Public utility assessments ............................................................................... 2,000 Public water supply fees ..................................................................... 27,300 Refined petroleum fund ...................................................................... 375,800 Sand extraction fee revenue ................................................................ 600 Scrap tire regulatory fund ................................................................... 30,200 Septage waste program fund ............................................................... 2,700 Sewage sludge land application fee ..................................................... 11,700 Small business pollution prevention revolving loan fund ................... 2,600 Soil erosion and sedimentation control training fund ……………….. 2,600 Solid waste management fund - staff account ..................................... 42,400 Stormwater permit fees ......................................................................... 18,300 Wastewater operator training fees ......................................................... 4,600 Water analysis fees ................................................................................. 18,300 Water use reporting fees ........................................................................ 3,100 State general fund/general purpose ........................................................ $ 565,000 Sec. 105. AIR QUALITY DIVISION Full-time equated classified positions ........ 187.0 Air quality programs--187.0 FTE positions ............................................ $ 27,944,100 GROSS APPROPRIATION .................................................................... $ 27,944,100 Appropriated from: Federal revenues: Federal funds............................................................................................. 7,392,300 Special revenue funds: Air emissions fees .................................................................................... 10,340,700 Fees and collections ................................................................................. 205,400 Oil and gas regulatory fund ...................................................................... 142,400 Public utility assessments ........................................................................ 150,000 Refined petroleum fund ........................................................................... 3,697,100 State general fund/general purpose .......................................................... $ 6,016,200 Sec. 106. RESOURCE MANAGEMENT DIVISION Full-time equated classified positions ........ 324.0 Drinking water and environmental health--120.0 FTE positions .............. $ 17,753,300 Drinking water program grants .................................................................. 830,000 Hazardous waste management program--45.0 FTE positions…………… 6,727,000 Low-level radioactive waste authority--2.0 FTE positions ....................... 238,700 Medical waste program--2.0 FTE positions .............................................. 313,600 Municipal assistance--29.0 FTE positions ................................................. 4,919,800 Noncommunity water grants ...................................................................... 1,905,700 Oil, gas, and mineral services--57.0 FTE positions .................................... 11,011,900 Pollution prevention--7.0 FTE positions ..................................................... 2,289,400 Radiological protection program--12.0 FTE positions …………………… 2,004,600 Recycling initiative--3.0 FTE positions ...................................................... 1,000,000 Scrap tire grants .......................................................................................... 3,500,000 Scrap tire regulatory program--10.0 FTE positions ................................... 1,356,900 Septage waste compliance grants .............................................................. 275,000 Solid waste management program--37.0 FTE positions ............................ 5,292,400 Water state revolving funds ....................................................................... 119,500,000 GROSS APPROPRIATION ...................................................................... $ 178,918,300 Appropriated from: Interdepartmental grant revenues: IDG from department of state police ........................................................ 1,691,300 Federal revenues: Federal funds.............................................................................................. 117,635,200 Special revenue funds: Private funds............................................................................................... 505,200 Campground fund ...................................................................................... 302,300 Cleanup and redevelopment fund .............................................................. 1,000,000 Coal ash care fund ..................................................................................... 260,000 Community pollution prevention fund ...................................................... 250,000 Electronic waste recycling fund ................................................................ 316,300 Environmental pollution prevention fund ................................................. 4,406,600 Fees and collections ................................................................................... 34,500 Medical waste emergency response fund ................................................... 313,600 Metallic mining surveillance fee revenue ................................................... 92,500 Mineral well regulatory fee revenue ........................................................... 208,000 Native copper mine fund ............................................................................. 50,000 Nonferrous metallic mineral surveillance ................................................... 369,100 Oil and gas regulatory fund ......................................................................... 5,818,000 Orphan well fund ......................................................................................... 4,239,600 Public swimming pool fund ........................................................................ 618,800 Public utility assessments ............................................................................ 238,700 Public water supply fees .............................................................................. 4,270,300 Refined petroleum fund ............................................................................... 721,400 Revolving loan revenue bonds .................................................................... 15,000,000 Sand extraction fee revenue ........................................................................ 85,800 Scrap tire regulatory fund ............................................................................ 4,856,900 Septage waste program fund ............................…………………………… 496,100 Small business pollution prevention revolving loan fund ........................... 134,400 Solid waste management fund - staff account ............................................. 4,716,100 Strategic water quality initiatives fund ........................................................ 1,220,500 Wastewater operator training fees ............................................................... 256,600 Water pollution control revolving fund ........................................................ 514,700 State general fund/general purpose ............................................................... $ 8,295,800 Sec. 107. REMEDIATION AND REDEVELOPMENT DIVISION Full-time equated classified positions ............................. 308.0 Contaminated site investigations, cleanup and revitalization--130.0 FTE positions ............................................................... $ 15,173,500 Emergency cleanup actions ........................................................................... 2,000,000 Environmental cleanup support .................................................................... 1,000,000 Federal cleanup project management--40.0 FTE positions…………….. 7,163,300 Laboratory services--39.0 FTE positions ................................................. 6,471,000 Refined petroleum product cleanup program--99.0 FTE positions .......... 34,849,000 Superfund cleanup .................................................................................... 1,000,000 GROSS APPROPRIATION ..................................................................... $ 67,656,800 Appropriated from: Federal revenues: Federal funds.............................................................................................. 6,480,300 Special revenue funds: Private funds.........................................………………………………...... 192,500 Cleanup and redevelopment fund ............................................................... 16,641,200 Environmental protection fund ................................................................... 2,107,000 Environmental response fund ..................................................................... 2,864,800 Laboratory services fees ............................................................................. 4,119,000 Landfill maintenance trust fund ................................................................. 31,000 Public water supply fees ............................................................................ 317,800 Refined petroleum fund ............................................................................. 32,765,900 Revitalization revolving loan fund ............................................................ 103,100 Water analysis fees .................................................................................... 2,034,200 State general fund/general purpose ........................................................... 0 Sec. 108. UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANK AUTHORITY Full-time equated classified positions .......... 5.0 Underground storage tank cleanup program--5.0 FTE positions ..................................................................................................... $ 20,044,300 GROSS APPROPRIATION ...................................................................... $ 20,044,300 Appropriated from: Special revenue funds: Underground storage tank cleanup fund .................................................... 20,044,300 State general fund/general purpose ................... 0 Sec. 109. RENEWING MICHIGAN'S ENVIRONMENT Full-time equated classified positions ......... 40.0 Mapping and other support--5.0 FTE positions ......................................... $ 4,300,000 Renewing Michigan's environment program--35.0 FTE positions ...................................................................................................... 69,000,000 GROSS APPROPRIATION ....................................................................... $ 73,300,000 Appropriated from: Special revenue funds: Renew Michigan fund .................................................................................. 69,000,000 State general fund/general purpose .............................................................. 4,300,000 Sec. 110. INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Information technology services and projects ............................................... $ 9,630,200 GROSS APPROPRIATION ......................................................................... $ 9,630,200 Appropriated from: Interdepartmental grant revenues: IDG from department of state police .............................................................. 25,800 IDG from state transportation department .............................................. 86,100 Federal revenues: Federal funds............................................................................................ 1,814,700 Special revenue funds: Air emission fees ....................................................................................... 680,500 Campground fund ...................................................................................... 8,400 Cleanup and redevelopment fund .............................................................. 808,900 Electronic waste recycling fund ................................................................. 6,500 Environmental pollution prevention fund .................................................. 469,100 Environmental protection fund ................................................................... 87,400 Environmental response fund ..................................................................... 169,100 Financial instruments ................................................................................... 1,653,500 Groundwater discharge permit fees ............................................................. 76,700 Laboratory services fees .............................................................................. 64,800 Land and water permit fees ......................................................................... 271,300 Medical waste emergency response fund ................................................... 10,000 Metallic mining surveillance fee revenue ................................................... 2,700 Mineral well regulatory fee revenue ............................................................ 4,900 Nonferrous metallic mineral surveillance .................................................... 300 NPDES fees .................................................................................................. 143,900 Oil and gas regulatory fund ........................................................................... 333,500 Orphan well fund ........................................................................................... 29,500 Public swimming pool fund ........................................................................... 15,100 Public utility assessments ............................................................................... 7,900 Public water supply fees ................................................................................. 151,100 Refined petroleum fund .................................................................................. 1,748,700 Sand extraction fee revenue ............................................................................ 2,300 Scrap tire regulatory fund ................................................................................ 64,300 Septage waste program fund ............................................................................ 11,300 Sewage sludge land application fee .................................................................. 22,900 Small business pollution prevention revolving loan fund ................................ 10,700 Soil erosion and sedimentation control training fund ………………………… 10,400 Solid waste management fund - staff account ................................................... 174,700 Stormwater permit fees ...................................................................................... 70,900 Wastewater operator training fees ...................................................................... 19,200 Water analysis fees .............................................................................................. 74,300 Water pollution control revolving fund ............................................................... 7,400 Water use reporting fees ...................................................................................... 13,300 State general fund/general purpose ..................................................................... $ 478,100 Sec. 111. ONE-TIME APPROPRIATIONS Drinking water declaration of emergency ........................................................... $ 100 GROSS APPROPRIATION ............................................................................... $ 100 Appropriated from: Special revenue funds: Drinking water declaration of emergency reserve fund ……………………….. 100 State general fund/general purpose ................................................................... 0" and adjusting the subtotals, totals, and section 201 accordingly Representative Brixie explained the amendment.
Meeting id: meeting-2578
Member id: member-121
Motion text: to adopt the amendments for HB 4233, as substitute (H-1).
Mover label: Cherry
Nays: 17
Passes: 0
Position: 9
Resolution method: unique surname
Result: not prevailed
Service id: service-499
Validation state: consistent
Yeas: 12

Follow the evidence

Search records related to this title Inspect coverage and known gaps Open the release-pinned JSON record

Cite this record

Michigan Legislative Activity and Evidence Dataset, release 2026-07-28.3, “Committee vote · not_prevailed · 12–17–0,” /committee-votes/committee-vote-264371.

/api/v1/committee-votes/committee-vote-264371